Transportation Demand Management Strategies in the Culver City VMT Tool
Introduction
This document provides an overview of the Transportation Demand Management (TDM) strategies included in the City of Culver City Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT) Tool. The VMT Tool estimates VMT and the potential VMT reductions available from certain types of project site modifications, programming, and operational changes collectively known as TDM strategies.
The effectiveness of each of the 10 TDM strategies included in the VMT Tool is based primarily on documentation and research identified in the California Air Resource Board’s Zero Carbon Building Study (ongoing), which draws from the 2010 California Air Pollution Control Officers Association (CAPCOA) publication, Quantifying Greenhouse Gas Mitigation Measures (CAPCOA, 2010) and additional research that has been published since 2010. Each of these studies include evidence pertaining to anticipated changes in travel behavior in response to TDM programs, pricing, or other factors. The methodology to calculate the anticipated VMT reductions is specified for each strategy in the pages that follow.
The effectiveness of TDM strategies to reduce VMT depend on the general context of a site, referred to as “place types” in CAPCOA. For the purposes of calculating the VMT reduction associated with the TDM strategies, the entire City of Culver City was classified as “Urban Low Transit” based on the existing land use characteristics of the City and the existing transit network, with the exception of the transit screening areas around the four major transit hubs which were classified as “Urban High Transit” (but screened out of VMT impact analysis).
The TDM strategies are individually described in this document, with individual levels of effectiveness identified. However, to ensure the effectiveness of TDM strategies is not overstated, the VMT reductions in the VMT Tool are both dampened and capped.
Dampening: Within each type of trip (home-based work trips, for example), a multiplicative dampening formula is applied. For example, if both Strategy A and Strategy B are applied, the combined effectiveness is not A+B, but rather 1-(1-A)*(1-B). This captures the reality that many people who would consider using Strategy B overlap with the potential market for Strategy A, and would choose A or B for each trip, but not both A and B.
Capping: For the full set of strategies selected across all trip types, a global maximum reduction of 40% is applied. This level of reduction reflects the CAPCOA maximum reduction for TDM measures.
In the pages that follow, the inputs required by the user are listed for each TDM measure. The other formula components are either coefficients identified in the research or predefined quantities based on the location of the project.
Culver City TDM Strategies
Parking Category
- Off-Street Parking Cost
- On-Street Parking Cost
- Parking Supply
Transit Category
- Transit Frequency
- Private Point-to-Point Shuttle
- Last Mile Shuttle
Commute Trip Reduction Category
- Commute Marketing Program
- Financial Commuter Incentives – Commuter Incentives
- Financial Commuter Incentives – Transit Subsidies
Site Design Category
- Pedestrian Network Improvements
Parking Category
1. Off-Street Parking Cost
This strategy implements parking pricing for off-street parking locations for residents, employees, and visitors to the site. Off-street parking refers to parking in a lot, garage, or other parking facility where the project developer or site manager can control the parking price. This strategy is appropriate for all land-use contexts and all types of development, and it applies to all trip types. This strategy should be used in locations where parking pricing is already present, and where the surrounding on-street parking environment is either metered or otherwise constrained. If this strategy is selected for visitors, the measure will affect the total VMT but will not affect the VMT metrics (VMT per capita and VMT per employee).
The maximum available VMT reduction from this strategy is 5.5%.
The formula used to calculate the reduction in VMT as a result of this strategy is as follows:
VMT Reduction = (Elasticity of Parking Demand to Parking Price) x (Percent Change in Parking Price) x (Percent of Trips Parking Off-Street)
User Inputs:
- Baseline Parking Price – enter the dollar amount of the parking cost (per hour or per day) that is required today to park on-site
- Proposed Parking Price – enter the dollar amount of the parking cost (per hour or per day) that the project will require to park on-site
- Select whether the measure applies to residents, employees, and/or visitors
Additional Factors:
- Constant elasticity of -0.11
- Percent of all trips parking off-street is assumed to be 70%, which is 5/6 of the existing trips made by vehicle (84%) based on the US Census’ American Communities Survey commute mode share information from 2017
Source:
The application and effectiveness of this strategy, including the factors and assumptions mentioned above, are based on the following research documents:
- Ottosson, D. B., Chen, C., Wang, T., & Lin, H. (2013). The sensitivity of on-street parking demand in response to price changes: A case study in Seattle, WA. Transport Policy, 25, 222-232. Culver City VMT Assessment – TDM Strategies Updated March 30, 2021 Page 5 of 16
- Pierce, G., & Shoup, D. (2013). Getting the prices right: an evaluation of pricing parking by demand in San Francisco. Journal of the American Planning Association, 79(1), 67-81.
- J. Peter Clinch and J. Andrew Kelly (2003). Temporal Variance of Revealed Preference OnStreet Parking Price Elasticity, Department of Environmental Studies, University College Dublin.
2. On-Street Parking Cost
This strategy implements parking pricing for on-street parking locations for residents, employees, and visitors to the site. On-street parking refers to parking along the curb on the streets within walking distance of the project site. This strategy would require coordination with the City of Culver City to implement. This strategy is appropriate for all land-use contexts and all types of development, and it applies to all trip types.
The maximum available VMT reduction from this strategy is 5.5%.
The formula used to calculate the reduction in VMT as a result of this strategy is as follows:
VMT Reduction = (Elasticity of Parking Demand to Parking Price) x (Percent Change in Parking Price) x (Percent of Trips Parking On-Street)
User Inputs:
- Baseline Parking Price – enter the dollar amount of the parking cost (per hour or per day) that is required today to park on-street near the project site
- Proposed Parking Price – enter the dollar amount of the parking cost (per hour or per day) that the project will require to park on-street near the project site
Additional Factors:
- Constant elasticity of -0.11
- Percent of all trips parking on-street is assumed to be 14%, which is 1/6 of the existing trips made by vehicle (84%) based on US Census’ American Communities Survey commute mode share information from 2017
Source:
- Ottosson, D. B., Chen, C., Wang, T., & Lin, H. (2013). The sensitivity of on-street parking demand in response to price changes: A case study in Seattle, WA. Transport Policy, 25, 222-232.
- Pierce, G., & Shoup, D. (2013). Getting the prices right: an evaluation of pricing parking by demand in San Francisco. Journal of the American Planning Association, 79(1), 67-81.
- J. Peter Clinch and J. Andrew Kelly (2003). Temporal Variance of Revealed Preference OnStreet Parking Price Elasticity, Department of Environmental Studies, University College Dublin.
3. Parking Supply
This strategy reduces the on-site residential parking supply below a baseline parking supply (typically the code requirement for parking provision without consideration of parking reduction mechanisms permitted in the code, or the amount of parking provided by similar spaces in similar locations). Reductions in parking supply could also result from variances sought by a project. This strategy is appropriate to use for residential developments and applies to Home-based Work (Production) and Home-based Other (Production) trip types. This strategy is 100% effective in Urban High Transit contexts and 50% effective in Urban Low Transit contexts.
The maximum available VMT reduction from this strategy is 5.5%.
The formula used to calculate the reduction in VMT as a result of this strategy is as follows:
% VMT Reduction = (Estimate of Baseline Vehicle Trips – Estimate of Proposed Vehicle Trips) / (Estimate of Baseline Vehicle Trips) * (R^2) Where Vehicle Trips = 0.7015 * (Parking Supply) – 0.1389; and R^2 = 0.4292 A 50% effectiveness factor is applied to Urban Low Transit contexts, which is the designated context for most of Culver City.
User Inputs:
- Base city code parking requirements – enter the number of spaces that would be required by direct application of the parking code (without integrating any parking reduction mechanisms permitted in the code), or the amount of parking typically provided by similar projects in similar locations.
- Actual parking provision – enter the number of spaces that the project will be providing.
Source:
The application and effectiveness of this strategy, including the factors and assumptions mentioned above, are based on the following research document:
- Schuett, Paine, Riessen, Schwartz, Ziebarth, Chan & Whinery. (2015). “Does Providing Parking Influence Auto Mode Share in an Urban Environment?” Transportation Research Board 95th Annual Meeting, 2016.
Transit Category
1. Transit Frequency
This strategy makes transit service more appealing by reducing headways and thereby reducing overall transit trip time, encouraging riders to switch from auto to transit use. This strategy assumes transit is already present in the project area, and it requires close coordination with the transit service operator in the area to demonstrate the assumed service improvements will be implemented by the time the project is open. The project applicant would typically be required to financially support the operation of additional service and demonstrate commitment and partnership with the transit service provider through formal documentation. This strategy is appropriate for all land-use contexts and all types of development, and it applies to all trip types.
The maximum available VMT reduction from this strategy is 0.6%.
The formula used to calculate the reduction in VMT as a result of this strategy is as follows:
VMT Reduction = (Elasticity of Transit Ridership to Transit Frequency) x (Percent Change in Transit Frequency) x (Existing Transit Mode Share) x (Ratio of Average Transit Trip Length to Average Vehicle Trip Length)
User Inputs:
- Baseline Headway – enter the existing peak period headways, in minutes.
- Proposed Headway – enter the proposed peak period headways, in minutes.
Additional Factors:
- Constant elasticity of 0.5
- Existing transit mode share – the percent mode share for transit in Culver City, which is 3% based on US Census’ American Communities Survey commute mode share information from 2017.
- Ratio of Average Transit Trip Length to Average Vehicle Trip Length is assumed to be 25% (summarized research literature demonstrated a range of 2% to 50%; 25% was used as a sensible mid-point)
Source:
The application and effectiveness of this strategy, including the factors and assumptions mentioned above, are based on the following research documents:
- Handy, Lovejoy, Boarnet, Spears. (2013). Impacts of Transit Service Strategies on Passenger Vehicle Use and Greenhouse Gas Emissions.
- Litman, T. (2004). Transit price elasticities and cross-elasticities. Journal of Public Transportation, 7(2), 3.
- Taylor, B.D., Miller, D., Iseki, H., & Fink, C. (2009). Nature and/or nurture? Analyzing the determinants of transit ridership across US urbanized areas. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 43(1), 60-77.
2. Private Point-to-Point Shuttle
This strategy involves the implementation of a project-operated or project-sponsored long-haul shuttle, transporting employees of the project site between the project site and residential areas. This strategy is most appropriate for application to very large project sites where employee residences are concentrated. For employment-oriented developments in Culver City, these private point-to-point shuttles may carry large numbers of employees to Downtown LA, the Valley, Long Beach, or other areas where a concentration of non-local employees may live. This strategy is appropriate for all land-use contexts. This strategy is appropriate for employment-oriented developments and applies to Home-based Work (Attraction) trips.
The maximum available VMT reduction from this strategy is 1.4%.
The formula used to calculate the reduction in VMT as a result of this strategy is as follows:
VMT Reduction = (Elasticity of VMT to Shuttle Mode Share) x (Percent Shuttle Mode Share)
User Inputs:
There are no user inputs for this strategy
Additional Factors:
- Constant elasticity of -0.27
- Percent Shuttle Mode Share (default) – this is based on the transit mode share for the project area, which is from the Culver City model
Source:
The application and effectiveness of this strategy, including the factors and assumptions mentioned above, are based on the following research documents:
- Handy, Lovejoy, Boarnet, Spears. (2013). Impacts of Transit Service Strategies on Passenger Vehicle Use and Greenhouse Gas Emissions.
- Litman, T. (2004). Transit price elasticities and cross-elasticities. Journal of Public Transportation, 7(2), 3.
- Taylor, B.D., Miller, D., Iseki, H., & Fink, C. (2009). Nature and/or nurture? Analyzing the determinants of transit ridership across US urbanized areas. Transportation research Part A: Policy and Practice, 43(1), 60-77.
3. Last Mile Shuttle
This strategy involves the implementation of a project-operated or project-sponsored shuttle, transporting employees of the project site between the project site and the nearest transit hubs. This strategy is most appropriate for application to very large project sites; smaller projects may also utilize this strategy through participating in a neighborhood shuttle with other projects in the vicinity. Shuttle service should not simply mirror existing service but should provide new opportunities for access to rail stations or transit hubs. This strategy is appropriate for all land-use contexts. This strategy is appropriate for employment-oriented developments and applies to Home-based Work (Attraction) trips.
The maximum available VMT reduction from this strategy is 0.8%.
The formula used to calculate the reduction in VMT as a result of this strategy is as follows:
VMT Reduction = (Elasticity of Transit Ridership to Transit Network Coverage) x (Existing Transit Mode Share) x (Ratio of Average Transit Trip Length to Average Vehicle Trip Length)
User Inputs:
There are no user inputs for this strategy
Additional Factors:
- Constant elasticity of 0.7
- Existing transit mode share – this is based on the transit mode share for the project area, which is from the Culver City model
- Ratio of Average Transit Trip Length to Average Vehicle Trip Length is assumed to be 25% (summarized research literature demonstrated a range of 2% to 50%; 25% was used as a sensible mid-point).
Source:
The application and effectiveness of this strategy, including the factors and assumptions mentioned above, are based on the following research documents:
- Handy, Lovejoy, Boarnet, Spears. (2013). Impacts of Transit Service Strategies on Passengers Vehicle Use and Greenhouse Gas Emissions
- Sadek et al. (2011). Reducing VMT through Smart Land-Use Design. NYDOT.
Commute Trip Reduction Category
1. Commute Marketing Program
This strategy involves the use of marketing and promotional tools to educate and inform travelers about site-specific transportation options and the effects of their travel choices. This strategy is most effective when it includes two-way communication tools or tools that would encourage an individual to consider a different mode at the time the trip is taken (such as an app or a daily email). At a minimum, this strategy includes regularly-updated educational and promotional materials, such as posters, info boards, and a regularly-updated website with information that a traveler could choose to read at their own leisure. This strategy also requires the presence of a staffed coordinator position to field questions, manage the regular updates of transportation materials, and explore additional marketing and communications additions to keep the program active and engaging over time. This strategy is appropriate for all land-use contexts and all types of development, and it applies to all trip types. This strategy can be used in conjunction with either Commuter Incentives or Transit Subsidies, TDM strategies with descriptions that follow on the subsequent pages.
The maximum available VMT reduction from this strategy is 3.2%
The formula used to calculate the reduction in VMT as a result of this strategy is as follows:
VMT Reduction based on a 3.2% blanket reduction of VMT based on the application of a commute marketing program at the site.
User Inputs:
There are no user inputs for this strategy
Source:
The application and effectiveness of this strategy are based on the following research document:
- National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2010. Traveler Response to Transportation System Changes Handbook, Third Edition: Chapter 19, Employer & Institutional Travel Demand Strategies. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
2. Commuter Incentives
This strategy involves the subsidization of commute cost for employees of the project site. The subsidy must be proactively offered to each employee at least once annually on an ongoing basis and must be provided for the entirety of the year on a daily, weekly, monthly or annual basis. This subsidy could be applied at the discretion of the employee to cover commute costs such as carpool/vanpool costs, carshare membership, bikeshare membership, or transit passes, or could be used by the employee for non-commute purposes in exchange for forgoing a parking space (i.e., parking cash-out). The value of the subsidy must be approved by the City. This strategy is appropriate for all land-use contexts. This strategy is appropriate for employment-oriented developments and applies to Home-based Work (Attraction) trips.
The maximum available VMT reduction from this strategy is 0.8%
The formula used to calculate the reduction in VMT as a result of this strategy is as follows:
VMT Reduction = (Elasticity of VMT to Commute Cost) x (% Commute Cost Subsidized) x (Ratio of Shifted Trip Length to Average Vehicle Trip Length)
User Inputs:
- Baseline Commute Cost – enter the dollar amount of average commute cost (per day, per week, or per month) per employee
- Commute Subsidy Amount – enter the dollar amount of commute subsidy (for same time period as for baseline) per employee
Additional Factors:
- Constant elasticity of -0.03
- Ratio of Average Transit Trip Length to Average Vehicle Trip Length is assumed to be 25% (summarized research literature demonstrated a range of 2% to 50%; 25% was used as a sensible mid-point)
Source:
The application and effectiveness of this strategy, including the factors and assumptions mentioned above, are based on the following research document:
- Dong, J., Davidson, D., Southworth, F., & Reuscher, T. (2012). Analysis of Automobile Travel Demand Elasticities with Respect to Travel Cost.
3. Transit Subsidies
This strategy involves the subsidization of transit fare for residents and employees of the project site. The subsidy must be proactively offered to each dwelling unit and/or employee at least once annually for a minimum of five years and must be provided for the entirety of the year on a daily, weekly, monthly or annual basis. The value of the subsidy must be approved by the City. This strategy assumes transit service is already present in the project area. This strategy is appropriate for all land-use contexts. This strategy is appropriate for residential and employment-oriented developments, and applies to Home-based Work (Production), Home-based Other (Production), and Home-based Work (Attraction) trip types.
In Culver City, many transit fare products are available that can pay for individual trips, unlimited trips on a single transit operator’s system, or unlimited trips on multiple transit operators’ systems, including Culver City Bus and LA Metro. For LA Metro, unlimited passes are available on a daily, weekly, and monthly basis, and can provide a per-trip discount if the rider exceeds a certain number of trips within the given time period. In addition, LA Metro offers several employer annual pass programs, including the Metro Annual Transit Access Pass (ATAP), the Metro Employer Pass Program (E-Pass), and the Metro Small Employer Pass Program (SEP), which offer steep discounts but require a high minimum threshold of participation amongst all employees. In the future, new pass options may become available and fare structures may change.
The maximum available VMT reduction from this strategy is 0.3%.
The formula used to calculate the reduction in VMT as a result of this strategy is as follows:
VMT Reduction = (Elasticity of Transit Ridership to Transit Cost) x (% Transit Cost Subsidized) x (Existing Transit Mode Share) x (Ratio of Transit Trip Length to Average Vehicle Trip Length)
User Inputs:
- Percentage of transit cost subsidized – enter the percent of the transit cost that is subsidized per person
Additional Factors:
- Constant elasticity of -0.28
- Existing transit mode share – this is based on the transit mode share for the project area, which is from the Culver City model
- Ratio of Average Transit Trip Length to Average Vehicle Trip Length is assumed to be 25% (summarized research literature demonstrated a range of 2% to 50%; 25% was used as a sensible mid-point)
Source:
The application and effectiveness of this strategy, including the factors and assumptions mentioned above, are based on the following research document:
- National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. (2010). Traveler Response to Transportation System Changes Handbook, Third Edition: Chapter 19, Employer & Institutional Travel Demand Strategies. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.